Welcome to Key Pizza
Key Pizza, located at 7003 Kennedy Ave, Hammond, IN, is a beloved neighborhood gem known for its exceptional stuffed crust pizzas and hearty submarine sandwiches. Customers rave about the restaurant's dedication to quality ingredients, highlighted by their signature pepperoni-stuffed crust that transforms each slice into a delightful calzone-like treat. With a commitment to community, Key Pizza has become a favorite among locals, receiving praise for their friendly service and impressive menu offerings, including massive pizzas and tasty appetizers like mozzarella sticks. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a first-time visitor, this restaurant promises a satisfying culinary experience that keeps patrons returning for more.
- 7003 Kennedy Ave, Hammond, IN 46323, United States Hotline: +1 219-844-3668
Welcome to Key Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hammond, Indiana. Located at 7003 Kennedy Ave, this eatery has woven itself into the fabric of the local community, offering not just pizza but a culinary experience that resonates with its patrons. Known for its stuffed crust and unique fold-over crust, Key Pizza serves up flavors that elevate the traditional pizza to new heights.
As you step into Key Pizza, a warm welcome awaits you from the dedicated team who take immense pride in their craft. Restaurant-goers rave about the quality and taste, with one customer, Umar Haque, exclaiming, “Amazing stuffed crust pizza! The owner and workers really care about the food that they create.” It’s clear that at Key Pizza, every pie is made with love and attention to detail.
Dive into their signature offerings, like the pepperoni-stuffed crust, which is not just a pizza but an experience of gooey, cheesy delight. Iris Fedorchak recommends it wholeheartedly, noting its impressive size and the delightful combination of flavors: “Their cheese has a greasy salty flavor... it really is delicious gooey goodness.” This is the kind of pizza that keeps you coming back for more.
But Key Pizza isn’t just about the pies; it’s also known for its submarine sandwiches, a tradition carried over from the beloved Super Submarine, which is now part of the Key Pizza family. As Lenny W puts it, “A Hessville neighborhood staple.” This fusion of classic sandwiches and pizza makes for a multifaceted menu that never disappoints.
For families and community groups, Key Pizza goes the extra mile, as Daddy Johnson attests to their generous spirit during his son’s birthday celebration, saying, “Thanks to you guys, my son and the other students at Autism Home Services had a good time eating pizza.” It’s this commitment to service that makes Key Pizza not just a restaurant, but an integral part of the neighborhood.
If you're in the area, don’t miss out on their lunch specials, which are famously affordable and consistently praised by customers like G M, who appreciates the friendly atmosphere and excellent pizza. Whether it’s a casual lunch, a family gathering, or just craving a slice, Key Pizza checks all the boxes.
In summary, Key Pizza is more than just a pizza place; it’s a community hub that delights with its exceptional food and dedication to quality. So, if you find yourself in Hammond, Indiana, make sure to visit Key Pizza. You won’t just be having a meal; you’ll be partaking in a local tradition worth savoring.

Amazing stuffed crust pizza! The owner and workers really care about the food that they create. Big fan!

Super submarine from across the street is now part of key pizza. Same sandwichs same people. Wonderful they didn't disappear forever. A Hessville neighborhood staple. Don't delay, go get one today!

I've been going to Key pizza for years and it has never changed. They have delicious pizza and I recommend getting the 'stuffed crust' or 'fold over crust' which basically makes the end of each slice of pizza like you have a calzone! the crust folds over some of your pizza ingredients and makes it so much more interesting than an average pizza slice. Their cheese has a greasy salty flavor and I mean that in the best way possible, it really is delicious gooey goodness. The sauce is great. And they offer a huuuuuuge pizza,which is impressive. I love Key!

Special thanks to key pizza! They went the extra mile when no other pizza place in the Griffith area would. Thanks to you guys my son and the other students at Autism Home Services had a good time eating pizza for his birthday! We will definitely use you guys in the future! P.s if I could give 6 stars I would

We went to Ninja Kidz down the street and kids had a hankering for pizza.I typed it in and took me to this place.Got a XL sausage/pepperoni pizza and I’m a pizza snob but this was one of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had!Got mozz sticks and chicken strips,they were gone before they cooled down.If I’m ever in the area again I’m def going back.

Always an absolute favorite!! I moved at AZ nearly 20 years ago and when I'm back in the region I always stop and grab a stuffed sausage pizza. No one makes them like Key Pizza

I was in the area and stopped for pizza. It was during lunch hours and they had a great affordable lunch special. The staff was very friendly and the pizza was excellent and plenty of cheese they way I like it. I will definitely stop at Key's Pizza again! Great pizza!

I haven’t been here in a while so I went last week. I was craving their pepperoni stuffed crust pizza. They add ground pepperoni inside the crust but I ask for it all over. In combination with the sliced pepperoni, it’s absolutely delicious. I love the taste of the thick layer of cheese and the crust is oh so good. One of my all time favorites. And the lady at the counter was very nice. Great job guys.